WWW.KOSHERDELIGHT.COM - GLOBAL JEWISH DIRECTORY WITH NEWS AND INFORMATION, TRAVEL, EDUCATION, PARENTING, HOLIDAYS AND MORE   כושר דילייט - מגאזין יהודי באינטרנט הכולל חדשות ומידע יהודי גלובלי. המגאזין כולל: בתי חב"ד, בתי ספר יהודיים, אוכל כשר ומסעדות כשרות, מקוואות, חינוך ועוד

   

Kosher Restaurants

Kosher Hotels

Synagogues

Kosher recipes

Mikvah

Jewish Holidays

KOSHER RESTAURANTS

KOSHER HOTELS

SYNAGOGUES

KOSHER RECIPES

MIKVAOT

JEWISH HOLIDAYS

                          ב"ה   
KOSHER DELIGHT - YOUR JEWISH ONLINE MAGAZINE!

Bullet Home
Bullet
SITE INDEX
BulletJEWISHKD.COM
Bullet
DONATE 

KOSHER
BulletKosher restaurants
   Around the World!
BulletKosher Hotels
Bullet
Kosher Recipes 

BulletVegetarian Restaurants
Bullet
Updates from the
   Chief Rabbinate of
   Israel

BulletKosher Alcohol Updates
Bullet
Kashrut Authorities
BulletKosher Products Lists

Bullet
Kashrut Comments

BET DIN OUTSIDE ISRAEL
BulletInternational Directory of Rabbinical Courts

SHABBAT
BulletCandle Lighting Times
   for Shabbat & Holidays


NEWS
Bullet
News & Media


JEWISH STUFF...
BulletJewish Simcha
BulletJudaism, Spiritualism,
   Opinions and more

Bullet
Jewish Communities
   Around the World

Bullet
Parashat
   HaShavuah
   
Bullet
Jewish Holidays
Bullet
Synagogues
Bullet
Mikvaot
Bullet
Chabad Houses
Bullet
Aish HaTorah
Bullet
Young Israel  
Bullet
NCSY
Bullet
B'nai Akiva
Bullet
Hillel
BulletThe Holocaust


PARENTING
BulletParenting
BulletJewish Camps
BulletKids
Bullet
Babies


HEALTH
Bullet
Jewish Hospitals
Bullet
Your Health
Bullet
Do not Abuse
    Drugs and Alcohol


FRIENDS ON 4
BulletOur Pets
BulletThe Dog Trainer: Q & A
BulletThe Veterinarian Corner
Bullet הטסת כלבים
Bullet כלבים: עכשיו הדיאטה
Bulletהיצלנו את לוקה


BulletInsurance New!
BulletQuestions & Answers
Bullet
Links


BulletCONTACT US!  


 
 
 

KD MAGAZINE! 
Posted: September 2, 2006 - מוצא"ש, ט' באלול, תשס"ו

 
 
 
   
 

An open letter to Mr. Balthasar Staehelin,
ICRC Delegate-General for the Middle East and North Africa
 
From Maurice Ostroff                         September 2, 2006
About the Author  
 
Sir,

Red Cross slams Downer's hoax claim
I refer to the above article of August 30, in the Australian and in News.com  in which the ICRC is reported to have rebuked Australian Foreign Minister Alexander Downer for relying on an unverified internet blog to claim an Israeli missile strike on one of its ambulances in southern Lebanon was a hoax
 
The claim by an ICRC spokeswoman that there was no evidence to support Mr Downer's assertion is evidently based on hearsay and is patently incorrect.
 
Journalists have stated freely that, as they are seldom able to gain access to sites of incidents in Lebanon when they occur, they rely on reports by local persons, most often Red Cross workers. The fact that such workers are drawn from the local population makes it unrealistic to rely on them to be unbiased.
 
In your recent BBC Hardtalk interview, you repeatedly stated that Red Cross workers are not permitted to give evidence as witnesses in any court hearings. A BBC profile of the ICRC (May 19), dealing with confidentiality and prisoners of war, reported that the ICRC does not discuss its findings, arguing that confidentiality enables it to access places that no other organization can reach.
 
But in Lebanon (and in Palestine), far from observing this policy, Red Cross workers have been vocal spinmasters, often contradicting each other and themselves, while enjoying immunity from ever having to substantiate their claims under cross-examination in a court of law. As Mr.Sackur so pertinently pointed out during the interview, this entails a glaring inconsistency.
 
Let us take, as an example, the much-quoted Red Cross worker, Qassem Shalin, a prolific source on whom the overwhelming majority of media reports have been based, and whose story changes form time to time.
 
Dahr Jamail, the award-winning, independent journalist reported that Shalin told him he was in the ambulance at the time of the bombing. However, in other reports Shalin was lifting the rear ramp of the ambulance when the missile hit. This would be quite a feat in view of the fact that according to other reports, including a July 26 article in the Australian, the two ambulances were traveling in convoy when "fired on by an Israeli Apache helicopter as they sped to the besieged port city of Tyre
 
The report added that the convoy was struck by two rockets fired from an Apache helicopter, just before midnight, severely injuring all six people on board. In other reports all six were not injured; Shalin escaped with light scratches.
 
Here we have an even more serious inconsistency, because on August 31 the Australian reported that the ambulances were not hit by rockets at all, but by missiles fired from a drone, not a helicopter.  This claim was confirmed by the group manager of the first-aid team for the Lebanese Red Cross, George Kettneh, who said "I am sure the missile was fired from a drone He also supports the version that Shalim was not in the ambulance, but was closing the doors when the vehicle was hit.
 
Shalin later told the Australian "There was not a sound in the sky before the explosions. And after that there was a battle for the next hour. We hid in a building nearby convinced we were going to die."
 
Nowhere else is a battle mentioned in relation to this incident. With whom?  With the drone or the helicopter? When the explosion occurred, was Shalin lifting the ramp or was he in the ambulance? In either case he was reportedly taken to Jamal Amal hospital. When then, was he hiding in a building?
 
To anyone who has seen pictures of buses attacked by suicide bombers in Israel, it is obvious from the pictures on Jamail's website that even a small bomb could not have struck the ambulance depicted. Comparing two photos from the site, an external view of a hole in the roof shows it as circular and clean cut, precisely in the position of the usual vent hole. It cannot possibly be the same hole viewed from the interior in another picture and claimed to be of the same ambulance but with very jagged edges and non-circular shape.  All the captions in Jamail's web page refer to one ambulance and show Kasssem Shaulan, looking unscratched though he claims on that web page to have been in the ambulance when it was bombed
 
When the ICRC spokeswoman says there was no evidence to support Minister Downer's assertion, is she accepting the self-contradictory reports by Mr. Shalin and other local workers as solid evidence? And does this flimsy evidence justify damaging allegations of war crimes by Israel, while giving no reason at all, for rejecting the responses of Israels spokespersons and the comprehensive, reasoned report in zombietimes blog?
 
It is also important to know why the spokeswoman completely ignores an AP report by Kathy Gannon, of July 25, stating that both ambulances were destroyed, thus repudiating all the photographic evidence of an ambulance with a hole in its roof?
 
Surely we are entitled to expect greater attention to rigorous fact-finding from such a great humanitarian organization as the Red Cross.
 
To quote Minister Downers speech to the National Newspaper Publishers' Conference, on August 28; . . . the first duty of responsible media is to get the facts straight, and to get the story right, even when that story might not necessarily conform to your own opinions or prejudices".
 
We owe a debt of gratitude to bloggers like zombietime and courageous statesmen like Australian Minister Downer for their serious contributions towards revealing the truth.


Read more articles by Maurice Ostroff


Mr. Ostroff's Website: http://maurice-ostroff.tripod.com

 

 
KOSHER DELIGHT - YOUR JEWISH ONLINE MAGAZINE! כושר דילייט - מגזין החדשות והמידע מהעולם היהודי ומישראל, כולל מסעדות כשרות, בתי כנסת ועוד ועוד

Zikit Translation Services

ZIKIT TRANSLATION SERVICES , שירותי תירגום, שרותי תירגום, שירות תרגומים, שירות תירגומים, שרות תרגום, תירגום, תרגום, תירגום מסמכים, תירגום תעודות, תרגום טכני, תירגום טכני, תרגום, תרגומים מעברית לאנגלית, תרגומים מאנגלית לעברית, תרגום עברי אנגלית אנגלי עברי -  זיקית שירותי תרגום

www.zikit.org


THE JEWISH HOLOCAUST
THE HOLOCAUST - THE SHOAH

Advertise with Us!

KD Kosher Recipe Collection
Send us your 
Kosher Recipe!


COMPREHENSIVE WORLDWIDE JEWISH SEARCH: JEWISHKD.COM Comprehensive Worldwide Jewish Search